Gerry and Susie Wagler

Original founders of Shakespeare Pies 

Background: When Susie decided to sell some of her delicious home-baked goods at a garage sale, little did she realize that one day this little start would turn into the dynamic family business that it is today! After that original sale they as a young family began a weekend roadside stand.  In 2003 they took the opportunity to move into the present location in the Shakespeare Plaza.  Today Susie is still very involved in the day to day activities of the bakery and her expertise and baking knowledge is very evident in our finished products. 

Kenton and Bethany Plett

Owner/Manager

Background: Bethany, daughter of Gerry and Susie, has always had a love for baking and has many fond memories of spending time at Shakespeare Pies with her mother and sisters.  In 2010 when Gerry and Susie were ready to take a more relaxed role in the bakery it was a natural fit for us, Kenton and Bethany, to come along side and work with them.  Today we spend many happy hours as a family working together to produce the very best pies, and other homestyle baked goods for our friends, neighbors, and folks that are travelling through the area.